Using an eyebrow pencil may look simple at first, but in reality it takes practice to master. The line between well-defined brows and overly dark ones is extremely thin. Many people realise this only after seeing old photos and wondering why no one told them their brows looked far too heavy.
Over the years, I’ve spent plenty of time figuring out how to shape my brows properly and define each hair in a natural way that suits my face. Because my eyebrows are naturally blonde while my hair is dark brunette, they need a bit more attention. The tail of my brow doesn’t grow fully, so I have to draw part of it manually every day. It’s not always easy, but after years of practice I’ve become quite confident with it.
Working as a beauty editor for six years has also helped a lot. The role gave me the chance to learn directly from some of the world’s best makeup artists and try many new brow products before they became popular. Through those experiences, I’ve gathered several useful techniques that can help anyone improve their eyebrow pencil skills quickly.
How To Shape Your Eyebrows With A Pencil
Beauty editors often test countless eyebrow pencils to find the ones that help avoid overly thin or unnatural-looking brows. Choosing the right technique can make a major difference in how natural your brows appear.
A soft 'curtain fringe' is the most flattering trend for mature hair – here's how to style it now
Many celebrity makeup artists recommend certain eyebrow pencils that help create smooth, realistic arches. These tools are designed to mimic natural brow hairs and give you better control when shaping.
Creating perfect brows can feel just as challenging as drawing symmetrical winged eyeliner. Many people spend extra time in front of the mirror trying to balance both brows, only to keep adjusting one side after the other.
During a fashion week backstage session, makeup artist Lisa Potter-Dixon shared a piece of advice that completely changed how I approach brows. She explained that “eyebrows are sisters, not twins.” In other words, they don’t need to be perfectly identical to look good. Instead of forcing symmetry, it’s often better to enhance each brow’s natural shape so it complements your face.
Preparing Your Eyebrows Before Using A Pencil
Before filling in the brows, preparation is important. I usually brush them with a spoolie and set them using eyebrow gel. However, one surprisingly effective trick is using a simple bar of soap.
The “soap brow” technique has become extremely popular in recent years because it helps create fluffy, lifted brows that stay in place. Many brands have released products inspired by this trend, but some professionals still prefer the original method.
Makeup artist Naoko Scintu, who has worked with celebrities like Priyanka Chopra and Jodie Comer, recommends using Pears soap directly from the bar. According to her, lightly dampening the soap and brushing it through the brows keeps them perfectly styled all day.
How To Draw Natural Looking Brows With A Pencil
When using an eyebrow pencil, the direction of your strokes matters a lot. Instead of drawing across the brow, create small upward strokes that mimic the direction of natural hair growth. Using the sharp tip of the pencil, make quick and light movements to produce hair-like lines.
Fill your brows vertically or at a slight 45-degree angle for the most natural look. Drawing horizontal lines across the brow can make them appear artificial because real brow hairs rarely grow that way. Observing the direction of your natural hair growth will help guide your strokes.
How To Prevent Overly Thin Pencil Brows
If you love the ultra-thin brow trend from the 1990s, this advice may not apply. But if you prefer fuller, modern brows, it’s important to be careful when shaping them.
Bobbi Brown senior professional artist Warren Dowdall suggests filling in your brows first before deciding which hairs actually need trimming or plucking. Once the brows are filled, it becomes easier to see what truly needs adjustment.
The key idea is simple: less is more. Over-tweezing can quickly lead to brows that become thinner than intended. I learned this lesson the hard way after years of shaping my own brows and occasionally removing too much hair.
Choosing The Best Eyebrow Pencil Brands
Once you understand the correct technique, the final step is choosing a good eyebrow pencil. The right product can make shaping easier and help create realistic strokes that blend seamlessly with your natural brows.
Here are some eyebrow pencil brands that beauty experts and editors frequently recommend for achieving clean, natural-looking arches.
